Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (2024)

You are here: Home / Recipes / Main Meals / Recipe: Classic Shepherd’s Pie (a comfort food recipe)

Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (1)

By Heather @ Team Crumbs Published Last Updated May 22, 2020 11 Comments

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (2)

I hope all of you enjoyed a restful and worshipful Christmas last week just as my family did! We had a wonderful time celebrating Christ’s birth and visiting family and friends.

But, for us, the week after Christmas is also a treasured time of relaxing and enjoying time together. My husband is home from work and we do our best to sleep in, lounge around, and watch as many bowl games as we possibly can!

Oh, the simple things!

After all the homemade eggnog and holiday cookies last week, it feels good to get back to the basics in the kitchen too – easybreakfasts, from-scratch soups, and simple family dinners return to the menu. And at the top of our list of family favorite dinner recipes is this Shepherd’s Pie.

Shepherd’s Pie – A simple and hearty comfort food recipe!

Shepherd’s Pie originated among poor farm families in Scotland and northern England around 150 years ago and, as its history suggests, it’s the most basic of comfort foods – meat, potatoes, peas, carrots, and a little cheese. Nothing fancy – just a delicious and hearty meal that your family will love!

I pride myself on cooking wholesome foods that my family enjoys. But, truth be told, there are only a handful of dinner recipes that every member of my family raves about – and this is one of them! I usually double the recipe and serve it two or three nights in a row, and I get clean plates back every. single. time.

Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (3)

Healthy and Affordable Comfort Food

In addition to the simple, savory flavor of this Shepherd’s Pie recipe, I love that it’s also healthy and budget friendly. All of the ingredients can be found at any local grocery store, and can easily be adapted to make it even healthier and more affordable.

Here are a few ideas for healthy and money-saving recipe adaptations:

  1. For grain free: substitute arrowroot for the flour.
  2. Boost the veggie value: Double the carrots and add half a bag of frozen English peas.
  3. Save money by reducing the meat and cheese: Use only one pound of ground beef instead of two. Likewise, the cheese can be reduced by half. We love the meatier version, but I made it with half the meat when I was in a pinch before and it was still wonderful.

From Tiff: I wonder if you could swap sweet potatoes for white if that’s what you had, or maybe even add some lentils or beans to help stretch the beef? What do you guys think?

Shepherd’s Pie – a Classic Comfort Food Recipe

Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (4)
Print Recipe
★★★3 from 1 review

When you’re looking for comfort food, nothing beats a classic shepherd’s pie. Simple to make, easy to stock & frugal to boot – as low as $1.73 per serving!!

  • Author: Back To The Book Nutrition
  • Prep Time: 30 mins
  • Cook Time: 30 mins
  • Total Time: 1 hour
  • Yield: 46 servings 1x
  • Category: Main Meals
  • Method: Oven
  • Cuisine: American

For the Mashed Potatoes:

  • 3 pounds Russet potatoes, chopped into 1″ pieces (I leave peels on for added nutrition, but you can peel the potatoes before chopping if you prefer)
  • 8 Tbsp butter
  • 1/21 cup milk or cream (I use raw), to your liking
  • Sea salt and black pepper to taste

For the Meat and Vegetable Mixture:

  • 2 Tbsp butter
  • 1 cup chopped yellow onion
  • 3 large cloves garlic, minced or pressed
  • 1/2 cup chopped celery
  • 2 medium carrots, peeled and sliced into rounds
  • 2 pounds ground beef (can reduce to 1 pound)
  • 1/2 cup beef broth/stock
  • 24 Tbsp flour (I like more for a thicker, gravy-like consistency)
  • 8 oz cheddar cheese, shredded (about 2 1/4 cups)
  • Sea salt and black pepper to taste

Instructions

For the Mashed Potatoes:

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Place potatoes in a large pot and cover with water. (Start chopping your vegetables while the potatoes cook)
  3. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat and allow to cook until soft (about 10 minutes). Drain.
  4. Slice butter into several pieces and add to the hot potatoes, allowing it to melt.
  5. Add the milk/cream and use an electric mixer to beat the potatoes just until smooth.
  6. Season with sea salt and black pepper to taste, then beat on high until the texture is to your liking.

For the Meat and Vegetable Mixture:

  1. Melt butter in a large saucepan.
  2. Add garlic, onion, celery, and carrot, and beef and saute, stirring often.
  3. Turn heat down to low and season with sea salt and pepper to taste.
  4. Heat 1/2 cup beef broth and whisk in 2-4 Tbsp flour until smooth. Pour over the meat/vegetable mixture, stirring well. Continue to cook on low heat until sauce thickens slightly.
  5. Transfer meat mixture to a 13×9″ casserole dish or divide evenly into 6 smaller bowls/bakers.
  6. Sprinkle shredded cheddar evenly across the top of the meat mixture.
  7. Spoon mashed potatoes on top and spread evenly across the surface with the back of a spoon.
  8. Cook for about 20 minutes or until mixture is heated through and the surface begins to firm slightly.
  9. I usually broil for 1-2 minutes to get a nice, light crisp and golden brown on the surface of the potatoes.

Notes

This dish can be assembled ahead of time and stored in the fridge until ready to cook, and it makes excellent left overs!

Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (5)

Cost Breakdown

Original Version

  • Ground beef: $9-14
  • Pastured butter: $0.63
  • Onion: $0.25
  • Celery: $0.25
  • Carrots: $0.25
  • Garlic: $0.25
  • Flour: $0.05
  • Beef broth/stock: free (from reserved bones)
  • Potatoes: $3
  • Milk: $0.30
  • Cheese: $1.75

Total Cost for Classic Shepherd’s Pie = $15.73 for six servings, or $2.62 each

If the budget is tight, reducing the ground beef to 1 pound and cutting the cheese to 4 ounces reduces the overall cost of the recipe to $10.35, or just $1.73 per serving!

Classic shepherd’s pie is hearty enough to serve alone or with just a simple and inexpensive green vegetable. There’s no need to add bread, salad, or other additional side items to make sure everyone has enough to eat.

How about you? How are you spending this final week of the year? What’s your favorite comfort food recipe?

Share this post:

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on PinterestShare on Email

You May Also Enjoy These Recipes

Food prices are going up, but your grocery budget doesn't have to! Join our free Fight Inflation Workshop to learn 3 simple yet proven strategies to save money on food week after week, even when prices keep going up!

Fight Inflation Workshop

About Heather @ Team Crumbs

Reader Interactions

11 Comments

  1. Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (11)Julie

    Hello from England!
    If it’s beef it’s Cottage pie. Shepherd’s pie is made with minced lamb. Never had cheese added to either, I think that’s an American thing.

    Reply to this comment

    • Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (12)Dena @ Back To The Book Nutrition

      Thanks for the expertise, Julie! 🙂 We spent some time in the English countryside a couple years ago and got to have traditional versions of both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie, along with Cornish Pasties. All were delicious and we loved taking in the scenery in your lovely country!

      Reply to this comment

      • Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (13)Lexi

        Does this dish freeze well? I’d love to make several of these at a time to freeze. If so, how would you reheat it?
        I plan on halving the beef & adding mushrooms & lentils to bulk it up.

      • Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (14)Karen @ Team Crumbs

        Hi Lexi!
        Yes, this recipe freezes well. Be sure it cools completely before freezing. You can cover it with foil and reheat it in the oven for around 1 hour at 350 degrees. Let us know how your recipe comes out! 🙂

  2. Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (15)Melissa

    I want to be sure I understand. Do you cook the beef prior to adding it in the stage of the other ingredients so that it can be drained? Or is the ground beef grease just left in the pie?

    Reply to this comment

    • Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (16)Dena Norton

      Good question, Melissa. I leave the grease in the mixture and love the rich flavor it adds to the dish. I buy pastured beef, so there’s really not all that much grease, and I feel good about the nutritional quality of it. If you like drier pie, or are using beef from feedlot cows, you could certainly drain the beef before adding the broth and flour to the pan.

      Reply to this comment

  3. Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (17)Jean

    I come from an Irish family and both in Ireland and here in the States, we forgo the cheese and often either have parsnips or turnips in our pie.

    Reply to this comment

    • Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (18)Dena Norton

      That’s so interesting, Jean! Do you still add carrots and/or peas, or just the parsnips or turnips?

      I’m not sure I could give up adding the cheese at this point, though – when it melts, it adds such a rich and creamy flavor without seeming “cheesy”. 🙂

      Reply to this comment

  4. Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (19)Tarynkay

    I like to further up the vegetable count by adding pureed cauliflower to the mashed potatoes

    Reply to this comment

    • Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (20)Dena Norton

      That’s a fantastic idea, Tarynkay – thanks for sharing! 🙂

      Reply to this comment

      • Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (21)Tiffany

        I second the fantastic idea note. Perfect for when you have just a little bit leftover from another meal!

Leave a Comment

Recipe: Classic Shepherd's Pie (a comfort food recipe) (2024)

FAQs

Why is shepherd's pie good for the elderly? ›

On the positive side, popular ready meal versions of dishes like roast dinners and shepherd's pie are good sources of protein, which is particularly important for the elderly.

What is traditional shepherd's pie made of? ›

Traditionally, shepherd's pie is made with lamb mince, vegetables and mashed potato. The meat is added to an aromatic combination of softened carrot, onion and celery, known in French cooking as a mirepoix, which is then loosened up with stock, Worcestershire sauce, tomato paste and bay leaves to make a tasty gravy.

What ingredients does shepherd's pie a traditional Irish dish contain? ›

I never shy away from the excuse to celebrate anything Irish. What's not to love about shepherd's pie? It's got ground beef, or lamb, with mushrooms, onion, corn, peas and carrots cooked in a delicious gravy sauce that's topped with a mashed potato crust that's baked in the oven.

Does shepherd's pie have gravy in it? ›

Talk about satisfying. Ground beef, vegetables, and gravy are baked under pillowy mashed potatoes. If it's not yet already, this will soon be a family favorite recipe.

What meat is best for elderly? ›

White meats like chicken or turkey are great meats for seniors to add to their diets. However, red meat offers benefits as well in the right quantities. The thing is to avoid fatty cuts and opt for more lean meat (in addition to moderating your red meat intake).

What food should not be served to elderly? ›

5 Foods Seniors Should Avoid
  • Fried Foods. Fried foods are especially unhealthy for seniors as they are high in saturated and trans fats, which can increase the risk of heart disease, stroke, and Type 2 diabetes. ...
  • Processed Meats. ...
  • Added Sugars. ...
  • Alcohol. ...
  • High-Salt Foods.
Feb 6, 2023

Why do Irish people eat shepherd's pie? ›

Sometime in the 18th century, a dish called “cottage pie” came about somewhere in the vast expanse of the United Kingdom and Ireland. It seems to have originated as a way for folks to make use of leftovers, in order to avoid waste, both of the food and money varieties.

What is a shepherds pie called when it is made from beef? ›

The main difference between Cottage Pie and Shepherd's pie is cottage pie uses ground beef, and Shepherd's pie uses ground lamb. Both pies are cooked with vegetables and gravy and baked under a layer of mashed potatoes. To make Shepherd's pie using this recipe, simply substitute ground lamb.

What country invented shepherds pie? ›

The dish originates from the British Isles, but some might argue that it is an Irish dish by origin. The name "Shepherd's Pie" was first recorded in an 1877 cookbook. In this same cookbook, it was noted that the dish was of Scottish origin. During the period between the 18th and 19th centuries, money was very tight.

Does shepherd's pie have cheese in it? ›

The Shepherd's Pie has saucy ground meat and vegetables covered in a a mashed potato crust, sprinkled with shredded cheese, and baked to bubbly perfection.

What is Costco shepherd's pie made of? ›

Ingredients: Beef and/or veal, vegetable sauce (water, onion, green peas, corn, seasoning [sugars [glucose solids, dextrose, maltodextrin], flour, modified cornstarch, canola oil, hydrolyzed soy protein, dehydrated vegetables, [ tomato, onion, beet, garlic], modified cellulose, beef extract, disodium guanylate, ...

What is cottage pie made of? ›

There is quite often confusion over the difference between Shepherd's Pie and Cottage Pie. Both are made the same way – a beef mince filling in a gravy sauce that is topped with mashed potato, sprinkled with parmesan then baked.

What can I use to thicken my shepherd's pie? ›

The easiest way to thicken shepherd's pie filling is by sprinkling a few tablespoons of flour into the ground beef mixture as it cooks before adding it to the baking dish. The starch in the flour will absorb the extra liquid and create a thick gravy.

What can I use instead of Worcestershire in shepherd's pie? ›

Soy sauce: Soy sauce offers a savory, umami-rich flavor that can substitute for Worcestershire sauce. Use it in equal parts or adjust to taste. Balsamic vinegar: Balsamic vinegar adds a slightly sweet and tangy flavor, similar to Worcestershire sauce. Start with a small amount and adjust to taste.

Why is my shepherd's pie sloppy? ›

If your casserole is too runny, chances are you either didn't add enough flour to thicken the gravy or you didn't simmer it long enough to reduce the liquid. Also, make sure your potatoes are thoroughly drained before making the mashed potatoes, so the topping is not too sloppy.

What is the significance of shepherd's pie? ›

A Brief History of the Shepherd's Pie

Shepherd's Pie is believed to have been invented in the early 1800s. During this time, housewives were struggling to find innovative ways to recycle the leftovers that their husbands and kids had turned up their noses at. Back then, the struggle was real just as it is today.

Is mashed potato good for elderly? ›

Tooth decay, tooth loss, or poorly fitting dentures might lead to discomfort and hinder one's ability to effectively chew hard-textured foods. For older adults who have difficulty chewing their food, cottage cheese, scrambled eggs, and mashed potatoes can be good soft food options.

What foods are good for elderly and why? ›

Your need for calcium for strong bones and teeth will increase, so extra serves of low fat milk, yoghurt and cheese are important. Other good sources of calcium are tinned salmon, sardines, leafy greens like spinach, kale and bok choy, sesame seeds (and tahini) and almonds.

What are mashed foods for the elderly? ›

8 Delicious Recipes to Try
  • Mac & Cheese. Everyone loves macaroni and cheese. ...
  • Pureed Cauliflower. It's quite easy to get your veggies into a delicious pureed form, and cauliflower is no exception. ...
  • Avocado, Chicken, and Potato. ...
  • Mango Banana Smoothie. ...
  • Pumpkin Soup. ...
  • Creamy Broccoli Cheese Soup. ...
  • Beef Stew. ...
  • Spaghetti and Meatballs.
Dec 18, 2018

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Stevie Stamm

Last Updated:

Views: 6299

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Stevie Stamm

Birthday: 1996-06-22

Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

Phone: +342332224300

Job: Future Advertising Analyst

Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.